- - - - - - - - - - - -



©Copyright 2011, 2012 Eric Wrobbel



Share |

Vintage original Standard SR-F22 transistor radio variant Argentina Standard SR-F22 transistor radio vintage technology MignonCollectible vintage Zenith Royal 500H transistor radio and knockoffRip-off of Sony TPS-L2 original Walkman tape player, Windsor radio

Sooner or later, the collector will come across another of some item already possessed. This new discovery seems somehow different than the one already in the collection. And it often is. This we call a variant.

This is a major fork in the road for a collector. To the variant, some collectors will say, “So what? I've got one like it. Close enough.” But other collectors, like me, will grab it right up, fascinated by the differences, and go right out in the hope of finding more variants.

When I began collecting transistor radios nearly three decades ago, I knew of no documentation at all about them. I assumed there would be maybe 50 or 60 models, tops, and I would try and get them all. Well, I was very wrong. There are many hundreds of models, thousands if you count all the variants. And yes, I am still trying to get them all.

 

Knockoffs

And then there are the knockoffs. Very different than variants, these are items that blatantly rip-off the design of another, different brand. Often amusing, these are the work of hacks with no greater hope than to ride the coattails of somebody better than them.

The Zenith Royal 500H is arguably the best sounding and best performing transistor radio ever made. And it was expensive ($59.95 in 1961). That’s it on the far left. Though I’m not wild about its styling, many people were, including the folks at Sanshin (Japan) who committed a 90 degree robbery on this Zenith.

Above are variants of one of the earliest pocket transistors from Japan (1958). Experienced transistor hounds will recognize the Standard SR-F22 (far right) and its Mignon variant as shown in my Standard Transistor Radios book. Variant cousins of these radios include the Hitachi TH-621, AMC TR-600, and the Lafayette FS-110. The radio above left is yet another variant, branded Standard, but with the tuning knob and grille of a Mignon. Found in Argentina, this radio has an ‘S’ logo that is unlike any other Standard logo I’ve seen anywhere.

The original Sony Walkman, the TPS-L2 got copied too, in the amusing piece of junk shown at right that isn’t even a tape player (it’s a radio). Presumably, it appealed to people who couldn’t afford a real Walkman but wanted to look like they could. See the real Walkman here.

While knockoffs are fun to collect, I avoid buying or using new products that are knockoffs (and they are everywhere!). Not only is it distasteful to me to give money to thieves, but I have found that people with no moral qualms about stealing design also have no moral qualms about cheating their customers as to quality.

A word about the “lesser” items in a collection

Some collectors want only the “best of the best,” the rarest and most desirable pieces. At least in my radio collection, I have taken the route of the “completist.” It takes up a lot of space, I must admit, but I find that even the less interesting and less important radios still somehow inform the others— often in unforseen and unpredictable ways. I have learned a great deal about these radios, much of it from the “lesser” radios that snobs shun.


 
This Windsor ST-1400 stereo AM/FM radio from Hong Kong (1982) rips off the look of the first Sony Walkman, right down to the orange “Hot Line” button on top.